Console Quarterly
Journal

Choose a world you want to spend time in

Our UK comparison sorts 18 games by the sessions they offer, with a weighted rubric, platform checks and a short quiz to help you make a shortlist.

Join the discussion

A world can make you want to play again before you have decided what you will actually do there. Night City invites curiosity about the sort of character you might build, while the frontier in Red Dead Redemption 2 makes the prospect of a long ride part of the appeal. Start with that pull, then ask what you want your next session to contain. An evening for following a character’s story, half an hour for practising a fight and a weekend for wandering with a friend call for different games. Genre gets you part of the way. Session length, company and appetite for repetition make the choice more specific.

The PC Gaming selection ranges from long single-player role-playing games to fast first-person action, fighting games and a sandbox built around observation. The Bandit Action selection groups crime stories, outlaw settings and historical action, with room for a synchronised puzzle game. The categories describe two routes through this comparison and can overlap in the skills they reward. If your favourite part of an open world is choosing a route through it, HITMAN World of Assassination and Assassin’s Creed Syndicate both warrant a look. If you want to follow a tightly directed period story, Mafia: Definitive Edition gives you a different kind of evening from a free-roaming trip through Los Santos.

Gameplay carries 35 per cent of the editorial score. Presentation accounts for 25 per cent, story and world for 20 per cent, and replay value and accessibility for 10 per cent each. A game can earn its place through distinctive movement, clear feedback or a memorable setting. The weights also explain why two games with different strengths can end up close together. For a reader buying one game to replay over several months, repeatable encounters may matter more than their share of the score. If a control or display option determines whether you can comfortably play, check that requirement before letting a combined score settle the purchase.

Work from the exact store listing when you turn a shortlist into a buying decision. A remake, an expanded bundle and an older edition can carry similar names and give you different content or requirements. On PC, compare the listed processor, graphics, memory and storage requirements with the machine you will actually use. For console play, verify the console generation, the edition and which controllers the game supports. Check account conditions and online compatibility before arranging co-op. If you split your time between a desk and a television, also consider where you can comfortably read prompts and reach the inputs a game frequently asks for.

The platform and hardware comparison helps you put those checks side by side. A controller purchase deserves the same attention to compatibility as a game purchase, especially if you want to use it across devices. The separate GameStop retailer section is where the edition discusses hardware retail. Finish with Find Your Game if several titles still fit. The three questions ask what you want to do, how you want to spend a short session and what kind of world draws you back. Use the result to pick a few reviews, then read their trade-offs against the time and equipment you have.

Hardware & merchandise at GameStop

We are an official affiliate partner of GameStop. We may earn a commission on qualifying purchases. GameStop.com is a US store that ships within the continental US.

GameStop (not GAMSTOP) is the retailer listed in this section.

Browse hardware at GameStop

PC Gaming

RPGs, horror, action and stealth: compare the style of play before choosing a platform.

A rain-soaked futuristic city with elevated roads and coloured reflections

Action RPG Elite

Cyberpunk 2077

Editorial score9.2/10

Night City is the reason to put Cyberpunk 2077 on a shortlist, and character building is the reason to give it several evenings. This single-player action RPG suits someone who enjoys deciding what sort of character to develop while following a story through a dense science-fiction world. A useful first goal is…

Best for: Character builds and a dense science-fiction setting.

Pros
A dense science-fiction setting and character builds give exploration and story sessions a consistent personal direction.
Consider
Build decisions and a sprawling setting ask for continuity. The exact PC edition requires a hardware check.
Read the full review
A windswept medieval village beneath a distant ruined castle

Fantasy RPG Elite

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

Editorial score9.1/10

Geralt’s journey makes sense as a long-form fantasy RPG for a player who considers side quests part of the appeal. You can choose an evening’s purpose by deciding whether to follow a particular quest or give yourself time to explore and see what draws your attention. The combination of choices and exploration…

Best for: Long-form fantasy adventures and side quests.

Pros
Geralt, the fantasy setting and side quests suit a sustained campaign with room to explore and make choices.
Consider
A long campaign can lose momentum between irregular sessions, and expansion contents depend on the edition.
Read the full review
A monumental science-fiction fortress above a volcanic canyon

First-person action VIP pick

DOOM Eternal

Editorial score8.8/10

DOOM Eternal makes movement and resource management part of its first-person action. An encounter gives you several things to think about at speed, from where to move next to when to switch weapons and how to manage what you have left. It suits a player who enjoys repeating a section to make…

Best for: Movement-driven combat and repeatable encounters.

Pros
Fast movement, frequent weapon choices and resource pressure give repeat encounters a clear purpose.
Consider
Quick reactions and frequent weapon switching make sustained concentration and comfortable inputs important.
Read the full review
An isolated stone village beside a dark forest at dusk

Survival horror Editor's Elite

Resident Evil 4

Editorial score9.3/10

The Resident Evil 4 remake follows Leon Kennedy on a rescue mission and gives its third-person action weight through limited resources. It suits someone who likes a clear story objective and wants each encounter to involve decisions about what to spend. A useful way to approach the game is to ask how…

Best for: Focused action and survival decisions.

Pros
The rescue story provides direction, while limited supplies give third-person combat lasting consequences.
Consider
Resource pressure can make a session demanding. The remake and the earlier release share a title.
Read the full review
A snow-covered village below a distant gothic castle

Survival horror VIP pick

Resident Evil Village

Editorial score8.5/10

An isolated village and a first-person campaign put atmosphere at the centre of Resident Evil Village. The angle suits a player who enjoys looking closely at a space and wondering whether it is worth exploring with the supplies they have. Tension comes from the setting and from choices about when to press…

Best for: Atmosphere and tense exploration.

Pros
A close perspective, isolated setting and limited supplies make exploration feel consequential.
Consider
First-person tension can make long sessions tiring, and expansion contents need a separate check.
Read the full review
An abandoned city avenue reclaimed by green plants in warm daylight

Narrative action Editor's Elite

The Last of Us Part I

Editorial score9.3/10

Joel and Ellie’s journey through a post-pandemic America gives The Last of Us Part I a clear centre. Choose it if you want your evening to follow two characters through a single-player story, with stealth and survival encounters giving you decisions to make along the way. Much of its appeal for that…

Best for: Character-led storytelling and focused journeys.

Pros
A focused journey gives Joel and Ellie’s story room to develop around stealth and survival encounters.
Consider
Story continuity matters to the experience, and hardware and accessibility checks depend on the platform.
Read the full review
A timber boat on a cold fjord surrounded by mythic mountain ruins

Action adventure Elite

God of War Ragnarok

Editorial score9.2/10

God of War Ragnarok follows Kratos and Atreus through Norse realms, which makes its setting and its central relationship equally relevant to a buying decision. It suits a player looking for an action adventure where there is a reason to pay attention to the characters between bouts of action. Setting aside an…

Best for: Mythological worlds and character-led action.

Pros
The Norse realms and the relationship between Kratos and Atreus give the action a strong story context.
Consider
The story benefits from continuity. Requirements and account conditions need checking on the chosen platform.
Read the full review
An empty martial-arts courtyard with lanterns and distant mountains

Fighting VIP pick

Mortal Kombat 1

Editorial score8.6/10

Mortal Kombat 1 offers a story campaign, a roster to learn and the Kameo partner system. For a player interested in short competitive sessions, a useful way to start is to choose one fighter and one partner, then spend several matches finding out what each contributes. That gives losses a purpose and…

Best for: Learning matchups and short competitive sessions.

Pros
Short matches, distinct fighters and Kameo partners offer several ways to practise, alongside a story campaign.
Consider
Learning matchups and partner choices takes time. Online modes and extra characters can carry separate requirements.
Read the full review
Rooftops and makeshift bridges above an overgrown abandoned city

Survival action Selected

Dying Light 2 Stay Human

Editorial score8.2/10

In Dying Light 2 Stay Human, first-person parkour makes the journey across the open world part of the attraction. If you enjoy learning routes and working out how to reach a destination smoothly, movement alone can give a session a purpose. Zombie combat and story choices give you other reasons to continue…

Best for: Traversal and open-world survival.

Pros
Parkour ties exploration to movement skill, while combat and story choices give longer sessions direction.
Consider
First-person traversal takes adjustment. Co-op planning calls for checks on conditions, editions and supported platforms.
Read the full review
An abandoned coastal boulevard with palm trees and bright afternoon light

Action RPG Selected

Dead Island 2

Editorial score8.0/10

Dead Island 2 makes close-range zombie action the main event in a first-person RPG set in Los Angeles. It makes sense for players choosing a session around melee combat and for friends who want a co-op game with an immediately recognisable focus. A group can decide in advance whether the first evening…

Best for: Close-range action and co-op sessions.

Pros
Close-range melee gives the action a clear identity, and co-op offers a reason to bring friends.
Consider
Repeated close-range encounters need to appeal on their own. Check online requirements and compatibility before co-op.
Read the full review
An elegant empty hotel terrace overlooking a Mediterranean harbour
Editorial score9.2/10

HITMAN World of Assassination rewards someone who likes to understand a location before acting. Agent 47’s sandbox missions make observation and disguises part of choosing an approach, and replaying a location gives you a chance to test what you thought you saw the first time. A good session can begin with one…

Best for: Planning and replaying sandbox missions.

Pros
Observation, disguises and multiple approaches reward learning a location and returning with a new plan.
Consider
The approach favours patient observation, and different packages require a careful comparison of included locations.
Read the full review
A colourful fictional Caribbean town with hills and weathered buildings

Open-world action Selected

Far Cry 6

Editorial score8.1/10

Yara gives Far Cry 6 a large fictional setting for exploration and combat. The useful question for a prospective player is whether they enjoy choosing how to approach a destination and leaving space to see what else is nearby. That freedom suits a long session with time for a detour and can…

Best for: Exploring a large world and choosing approaches.

Pros
A large island and a choice of approaches suit players who enjoy setting their own exploration goals.
Consider
A broad map can make short sessions feel unfocused. Edition, account and co-op details are worth checking separately.
Read the full review

Bandit Action

Crime stories, western journeys and tactical puzzles. These six selections take different approaches to their worlds.

A fictional sunlit west-coast city with freeways and distant hills

Open-world crime Elite

Grand Theft Auto V

Editorial score9.0/10

Los Santos is both the setting for a crime story and a place to spend time between story objectives. Grand Theft Auto V follows three protagonists, so it suits someone who enjoys seeing an open world through several characters and who is happy to spend part of an evening on activities outside…

Best for: An urban sandbox with several protagonists.

Pros
Three protagonists and an urban sandbox give players room for structured story sessions and free exploration.
Consider
Open-world detours can stretch a session. Legacy and Enhanced have different requirements, so check the exact listing.
Read the full review
A wooden frontier settlement beside pine forest and a broad mountain valley

Western adventure Editor's Elite

Red Dead Redemption 2

Editorial score9.3/10

Arthur Morgan and the Van der Linde gang anchor a western about a changing frontier. Red Dead Redemption 2 suits a player who wants the time spent crossing that landscape to be part of the evening. Its deliberate pace makes more sense when you are happy to give a journey space, explore…

Best for: A slower western journey and world exploration.

Pros
A changing frontier and Arthur’s place in the gang give the slower journeys a strong sense of purpose.
Consider
Deliberate pacing will feel slow to some players, and storage deserves a careful check.
Read the full review
A fictional 1930s city street with a period sedan and warm street lamps

Crime adventure Selected

Mafia: Definitive Edition

Editorial score8.3/10

Tommy Angelo’s story in the fictional 1930s city of Lost Heaven is the main reason to choose Mafia: Definitive Edition. This remake of the first Mafia story suits a player who likes the idea of returning to the same characters over several evenings and wants a period setting to give the story…

Best for: A focused period crime story.

Pros
Lost Heaven and Tommy’s journey give the remake a focused period crime story to follow.
Consider
A story-led structure offers fewer reasons for open-ended returns once the central campaign has served its purpose.
Read the full review
A busy-looking but empty Hong Kong-inspired night street with illuminated market stalls

Open-world crime Selected

Sleeping Dogs

Editorial score8.2/10

Sleeping Dogs brings martial arts, driving and an undercover story together in a single-player crime adventure set in Hong Kong. It suits someone who wants close-range action to give a city game its own character, while still having room to get behind the wheel and follow the next development in the story…

Best for: Martial-arts action and an undercover narrative.

Pros
Martial-arts combat, driving and an undercover narrative give the Hong Kong setting several kinds of session.
Consider
The shifts between driving and fighting may suit some players more than others. Verify compatibility for this older release.
Read the full review
An industrial Birmingham-inspired canal with brick warehouses and drifting morning mist

Puzzle adventure Selected

Peaky Blinders: Mastermind

Editorial score7.4/10

Mastermind uses the television series as the basis for a puzzle adventure about coordinating several characters on one timeline. The appeal is in making separate actions fit together, so it suits someone who likes working backwards from a result and asking where the timing first went wrong. A short sitting can have…

Best for: Planning and synchronised character puzzles.

Pros
Synchronised character actions give each timeline problem a clear structure and reward patient planning.
Consider
Timeline puzzles make for a specialised experience, and regional availability requires checking.
Read the full review
Victorian London rooftops above a foggy street and a railway station

Historical action Selected

Assassin's Creed Syndicate

Editorial score8.2/10

Victorian London gives Assassin’s Creed Syndicate its sense of place, while Jacob and Evie Frye give the action adventure two central characters to follow. It fits a player who likes learning a city by moving through it and taking time to think about a stealth approach. Traversal and gang conflict provide different…

Best for: Historical city exploration and stealth.

Pros
Victorian London, stealth and traversal give the city an active role in how you spend a session.
Consider
The city and gang conflict are central to the appeal. Older-release compatibility and account conditions need verifying.
Read the full review

How we choose and score games

Scores are editorial assessments based on the cited product information and the weighted rubric below. Use them alongside genre, edition details and the kind of session you want. A higher score can still be a poor fit for your preferences.

  • Gameplay (35%)
  • Presentation (25%)
  • Story / world (20%)
  • Replay value (10%)
  • Accessibility (10%)

Each criterion is assessed on a ten-point scale. The weighted result is rounded to one decimal place. Our selection covers paid games for an adult readership; check each product’s own age classification.

Gaming sites comparison

Compare games and their official product destinations. Scores refer to the game; check the linked listing for edition details, requirements and regional availability.

GameEditorial scoreProsConsiderWhere to play
Cyberpunk 2077Editorial score9.2/10A dense science-fiction setting and character builds give exploration and story sessions a consistent personal direction.Build decisions and a sprawling setting ask for continuity. The exact PC edition requires a hardware check.Check official listing
The Witcher 3: Wild HuntEditorial score9.1/10Geralt, the fantasy setting and side quests suit a sustained campaign with room to explore and make choices.A long campaign can lose momentum between irregular sessions, and expansion contents depend on the edition.Check official listing
DOOM EternalEditorial score8.8/10Fast movement, frequent weapon choices and resource pressure give repeat encounters a clear purpose.Quick reactions and frequent weapon switching make sustained concentration and comfortable inputs important.Check official listing
Resident Evil 4Editorial score9.3/10The rescue story provides direction, while limited supplies give third-person combat lasting consequences.Resource pressure can make a session demanding. The remake and the earlier release share a title.Check official listing
Resident Evil VillageEditorial score8.5/10A close perspective, isolated setting and limited supplies make exploration feel consequential.First-person tension can make long sessions tiring, and expansion contents need a separate check.Check official listing
The Last of Us Part IEditorial score9.3/10A focused journey gives Joel and Ellie’s story room to develop around stealth and survival encounters.Story continuity matters to the experience, and hardware and accessibility checks depend on the platform.Check official listing
God of War RagnarokEditorial score9.2/10The Norse realms and the relationship between Kratos and Atreus give the action a strong story context.The story benefits from continuity. Requirements and account conditions need checking on the chosen platform.Check official listing
Mortal Kombat 1Editorial score8.6/10Short matches, distinct fighters and Kameo partners offer several ways to practise, alongside a story campaign.Learning matchups and partner choices takes time. Online modes and extra characters can carry separate requirements.Check official listing
Dying Light 2 Stay HumanEditorial score8.2/10Parkour ties exploration to movement skill, while combat and story choices give longer sessions direction.First-person traversal takes adjustment. Co-op planning calls for checks on conditions, editions and supported platforms.Check official listing
Dead Island 2Editorial score8.0/10Close-range melee gives the action a clear identity, and co-op offers a reason to bring friends.Repeated close-range encounters need to appeal on their own. Check online requirements and compatibility before co-op.Check official listing
HITMAN World of AssassinationEditorial score9.2/10Observation, disguises and multiple approaches reward learning a location and returning with a new plan.The approach favours patient observation, and different packages require a careful comparison of included locations.Check official listing
Far Cry 6Editorial score8.1/10A large island and a choice of approaches suit players who enjoy setting their own exploration goals.A broad map can make short sessions feel unfocused. Edition, account and co-op details are worth checking separately.Check official listing
Grand Theft Auto VEditorial score9.0/10Three protagonists and an urban sandbox give players room for structured story sessions and free exploration.Open-world detours can stretch a session. Legacy and Enhanced have different requirements, so check the exact listing.Check official listing
Red Dead Redemption 2Editorial score9.3/10A changing frontier and Arthur’s place in the gang give the slower journeys a strong sense of purpose.Deliberate pacing will feel slow to some players, and storage deserves a careful check.Check official listing
Mafia: Definitive EditionEditorial score8.3/10Lost Heaven and Tommy’s journey give the remake a focused period crime story to follow.A story-led structure offers fewer reasons for open-ended returns once the central campaign has served its purpose.Check official listing
Sleeping DogsEditorial score8.2/10Martial-arts combat, driving and an undercover narrative give the Hong Kong setting several kinds of session.The shifts between driving and fighting may suit some players more than others. Verify compatibility for this older release.Check official listing
Peaky Blinders: MastermindEditorial score7.4/10Synchronised character actions give each timeline problem a clear structure and reward patient planning.Timeline puzzles make for a specialised experience, and regional availability requires checking.Check official listing
Assassin's Creed SyndicateEditorial score8.2/10Victorian London, stealth and traversal give the city an active role in how you spend a session.The city and gang conflict are central to the appeal. Older-release compatibility and account conditions need verifying.Check official listing

Hardware platforms comparison

PlatformWhere to PlayWhere to Buy
PCCheck the game’s PC listingBrowse hardware at GameStop
PlayStationCheck the PlayStation StoreBrowse hardware at GameStop
XboxCheck the Xbox storeBrowse hardware at GameStop
Nintendo SwitchCheck Nintendo eShopBrowse hardware at GameStop
CloudCheck Xbox Cloud GamingDigital service

Comments